Why Reviews Matter: The Key to Short-Term Rental Success

As a property owner, choosing the right management company can feel overwhelming. Many homeowners in Nashville are drawn to big-name property managers, lured by their nationwide track records, local offices, and impressive portfolios. The assumption? More houses, more staff, and more experience must mean more cash flow at the end of each month.

Time and time again, we've seen this isn't the case. Instead, many homeowners find themselves locked into rigid contracts with disappointing results—sometimes even forced to sell an investment they worked so hard to acquire.

After five years of hosting in Nashville, our track record speaks for itself. We have never had a homeowner switch to us from a big management company and regret it. So what’s the difference? It’s simple: reviews.

The Power of Reviews

Reviews are the backbone of booking platforms. They’re not just a reference point for potential guests; they’re the heartbeat of Airbnb, VRBO, and every major platform's ranking algorithm. These platforms analyze guest feedback—good, bad, and everything in between—to determine which listings deserve higher visibility.

Yet, many large property managers seem to ignore this crucial piece of the puzzle. Take a look at their Airbnb profiles, and you’ll see a pattern: declining ratings, lackluster guest experiences, and a revolving-door mentality that prioritizes quick turnovers over quality stays. They focus on maximizing short-term profits but fail to recognize that poor guest experiences lead to long-term revenue loss.

What Sets Us Apart?

We care. Not just in words, but in action.

I started this company from the ground up, personally handling guest concerns at all hours of the night. I understood that every guest chose our home for a reason—whether for a family getaway, a celebration, or a much-needed escape. They trusted us, and in return, we owed them an experience worth remembering.

That same guest-first mindset runs through every member of our team. We prioritize communication, attention to detail, and proactive hospitality. And the results speak for themselves: higher ratings, better search placement, and the ability to command premium rates. Guests will pay more for peace of mind, knowing they’re booking with a team that genuinely cares.

Choosing the Right Property Manager

Before you sign on the dotted line with any property manager, ask to see their reviews. Not just their overall ratings, but individual guest experiences. Are they consistently delivering exceptional stays, or are they just cycling guests through the door?

And here’s one more tip—ask to speak with their current clients from the last six to twelve months. Their experiences will tell you everything you need to know.

At the end of the day, reviews aren’t just feedback—they’re the foundation of success in short-term rentals. Choose a management company that understands their value, and your investment will thrive.

Back to blog